Former U.S. trade officials back court challenge to Trump tariff hitting Mariposa cheese
Three former senior U.S. trade officials, including NAFTA negotiator Carla Hills, have asked a New York court to strike down the 50 per cent tariff hitting Mariposa Dairy’s goat cheese.
Their Nov. 12 friend of the court brief to the U.S. Court of International Trade doesn’t oppose tariffs in principle. It argues U.S. President Donald Trump used a 1930 law that Congress replaced decades ago with rules requiring public hearings and an economic review. The old law “is not dormant; it is dead,” they wrote. All three served under Republican presidents, including one who also served under Jimmy Carter.
The case was filed Oct. 20 by Gellert Global Group, the New Jersey importer that brings Mariposa Dairy’s Celebrity goat cheese into the U.S. Gellert says it is absorbing the tariff through the end of this year, but can’t do so indefinitely. About 80 per cent of the Lindsay, Ont., plant’s cheese goes south, a blow Mariposa CEO Mark Anderson recently warned The Lindsay Advocate “will decimate our industry” if left in place.
What it means for workers and farmers
Nothing changes yet. The tariff stays in place while the case is heard, leaving roughly 200 Mariposa employees and 198 Ontario goat-farming families in limbo.
Key dates
-
Dec. 11: The U.S. government responds.
-
Jan. 11: Gellert replies.
-
To be set: A court hearing, after written filings wrap up in mid-January.
Either side could appeal a ruling. If Gellert wins, the tariff could be struck down and importers could get refunds.
Talks between Ottawa and Washington are a separate route to relief. No deal has been announced.

