When the province picks your head of local government
Queen’s Park has appointed the heads of eight regional governments, including neighbouring Durham Region, Simcoe County and the District of Muskoka. Kawartha Lakes voters still choose their mayor.
Durham Region voters have elected their regional chair since 2014. This fall, Ontario’s municipal affairs minister made the choice for them.
There was no regional chair race on Durham’s Oct. 26 municipal ballot. The province had already changed the rules.
On Nov. 10, Municipal Affairs and Housing Minister Rob Flack named the heads of eight upper-tier governments. Pickering Mayor Kevin Ashe will chair Durham Region. Outgoing Orillia mayor Don McIsaac will lead Simcoe County as county chair, replacing the title of warden.
Both regions border Kawartha Lakes. So does the District of Muskoka, where outgoing Conservative MP Scott Aitchison has been appointed chair.
The changes are close to home.
The Better Regional Governance Act, 2026, passed May 7, allows the minister to appoint heads of council in eight upper-tier municipalities. It also gives those appointees strong-chair powers, modelled on Ontario’s strong-mayor system.
They can hire or fire senior administrators, direct municipal staff, propose budgets and veto certain bylaws, within limits set by provincial law.
These are not ceremonial positions. They carry substantial authority over how regional governments operate, spend money and set priorities.
Premier Doug Ford has made no secret of his frustration with regional governments.
At an April news conference in North Bay, Ford complained that regional governments were getting in the way of mayors trying to move projects forward.
“They’re getting in the way of getting productivity done,” Ford said, according to The Trillium.
Ford said his government would streamline the system and make it more efficient. He also said appointed chairs should follow the mandate his provincial government was elected to carry out.
Flack offered a similar explanation when introducing the legislation, saying the appointments would help ensure regional governments were “in sync” with provincial priorities.
Those are legitimate objectives. Municipalities face growing demands for housing, roads and infrastructure, often with limited resources.
But efficiency and democratic accountability are not the same thing.
Who should choose the person exercising those powers — local voters, their elected representatives or the provincial government?
Durham voters lose their say.
In a 2010 referendum, nearly 80 per cent of voters who answered the question supported directly electing the regional chair. Turnout was below the threshold needed to make the result binding, but regional council voted 24-2 in 2012 to adopt direct elections anyway.
Residents first elected their chair in 2014. That choice is now gone.
Waterloo residents have elected their regional chair directly since 1997, and Halton residents since 2000. In Simcoe and Muskoka, elected councillors previously selected their heads of council.
Niagara, Peel and York already had provincially appointed chairs for the 2022-2026 term. The new legislation continues that authority and extends it to five additional governments.
The legislation also reduces the size of two councils for the new term, from 32 members to 13 in Niagara and from 32 to 17 in Simcoe County.
The changes affect more than who occupies the chair. They also change the number of elected representatives participating in regional decisions.
Kawartha Lakes is different.
As a single-tier municipality, Kawartha Lakes is not covered by these appointment provisions. Residents continue to elect their mayor directly, and the office carries strong-mayor powers.
Mayor-elect Charles McDonald received 13,542 votes in the Oct. 26 municipal election, securing a majority of votes cast for mayor. He was sworn in Nov. 16.
In Kawartha Lakes, the person exercising those enhanced powers must seek a mandate from local voters. Residents can examine the mayor’s record, challenge decisions and ultimately vote for someone else.
In neighbouring Durham, the regional chair receives the appointment from the province, although regional councillors remain elected.
The legislation adds another significant provision. The minister can, by order, remove a regional head of council and appoint a replacement. If the minister leaves the initial choice to council, that selection can still be overruled.
For the eight affected municipalities, Queen’s Park now controls who occupies the top job and retains the authority to remove that person.
The appointees bring different backgrounds and experience. Several are current or former mayors. Their qualifications deserve scrutiny, but that is separate from how they came to hold office.
Kawartha Lakes was never on the list, and there is no evidence the province intends to replace its elected mayor with an appointee.
Still, the city shares boundaries with three uppertier governments operating under this provincial appointment system. Roads, growth, economic development and public services do not stop at municipal boundaries. Decisions made by neighbouring governments can affect communities on both sides.
A choice worth keeping.
We elect our mayor. We can hold that mayor accountable at the ballot box. Whatever we think of the person occupying the office, that choice belongs to us.
In parts of Ontario, residents have lost that direct choice for their regional head of government. Elsewhere, elected councils have lost the authority to make it.
The question is not whether the province has appointed capable people.
The question is why the province, rather than local voters or their elected representatives, should make that choice.


