Wonder and innocence at the heart of Elf at Academy Theatre
Lindsay never had the equivalent of a Macy’s department store. J. Sutcliffe & Sons’ new building on the south side of Kent Street, which opened for the holiday shopping season of 1930, might have filled the void – but impressive though it was, this long-gone landmark lacked the mystique associated with the fabled retailer in New York City. For most local residents, a trip to Macy’s was but a distant dream.
A mammoth department store Lindsay might have lacked, but visits from Santa Claus were par for the course in communities like Lindsay when December rolled around. And when the jolly old elf showed up in person – as he did in 1928, arriving in Lindsay by way of Canadian National Railways, under the auspices of J. Sutcliffe & Sons – the occasion naturally warranted comment in the local press.
One wonders how the local media would have reacted had a jovial character showed up at Santa’s dais in the Sutcliffe store claiming that he had been orphaned in Lindsay, taken to the North Pole as a child, and raised as an elf. That’s exactly the premise (albeit set in Manhattan, not Lindsay) of Elf, which promises to entertain audiences at the Academy Theatre later this month.
Kawartha Lakes Weekly paid the theatre a visit last month where cast and crew were busily milling about under the watchful eye of director Beth Wilson, who runs the show with the precision of a department store manager gearing up for the busy holiday season. Elves in seemingly every colour combination imaginable troop across the stage, giving the rest of the room a taste of costume designer Jennifer Simpson’s talents in crafting an aesthetic that is at once thoroughly modern yet nostalgic.
“I chose Elf for those who are a kid at heart – myself included,” Wilson says. “They find joy in a random act of kindness, burst out randomly in song and love the kick of a little bit of maple syrup. Elf has been on my must-do list for a few years, so when we received a yes to licensing we jumped on it. It is also a show that appeals to so many through the movie as well as creating a special family event at the beginning of the Christmas season.”
The principal performers in Elf concur. “Buddy has an innocence to him, but also a sense of wonder,” says Paul Marshall, who has been cast as the energetic protagonist. “Audiences will think about the extent to which they hold onto those traits which are so common in childhood, but are so critical for experiencing joy and connection throughout adulthood. I have seen the film many times, but in performing the character I have really tried to focus on these ideas of awe and wonder and innocence, given that Buddy is coming from a world of magic and confronting the realities of life.”
Kaylan Lindsay, a veteran of many musicals at the Academy, takes on the role of Jovi, the cynical Macy’s employee who in due time becomes Buddy the Elf’s romantic interest. For her, Elf has much to teach a fast-paced, anxious world. “There is a lot of messaging in this musical that stresses the importance of making time for family traditions or something you’re doing in the community,” Lindsay explains. “There is an importance in having a little bit of whimsy in your life to balance out all of the other terrible things that are happening elsewhere in the world,” she continues. “If we don’t find those little moments of joy and connection, then we risk losing something.”
That’s a point that rings especially true for Tim Brown, who plays Buddy’s dour, workaholic father, Walter Hobbs. “Nowadays, in particular, that is a sentiment that probably rings true for a lot of people,” Brown reflects. “They kind of lose perspective on what it is they’re working for, who it is they’re working for.” By the second half of the musical, Walter Hobbs’ character softens a little, à la Dickens’ Ebeneezer Scrooge, and Brown hopes audiences will see a life lesson in that.
Like those in the employ of Santa’s workshop at the North Pole, live theatre demands the utmost in creative problem-solving. “As opposed to other years where you could have a stand alone set, Elf takes place in many different settings,” Wilson says. “So we really had to think about the realities of what our little theatre can accommodate in the wings and overhead and even take into consideration the amount of movement for our stagehands. We decided to use a standalone platform for some height along with sliding staircases that can be moved to various formations.”
Jude Collver, cast as Buddy’s brother, Michael, Elf is adamant that the value of family is at the core of the story – something Wilson, too, emphasizes. “You can experience collective effervescence which is the sense of unity people have when they come together as a group and share in a moment all together. What a fabulous way to build community!”
Elf goes up at the Academy Theatre on Nov. 26 (7:30 p.m.), 27 (2:00 and 7:30 p.m.), 28 (2:00 p.m. and 7:30 p.m.) and 29 (2:00 p.m.). For tickets and additional information, visit flatoacademytheatre.com.


